THE WILL AND THE WILDS by Charlie N. Holmberg – Review

I received this book for free from the Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

THE WILL AND THE WILDS by Charlie N. Holmberg – ReviewThe Will and the Wilds by Charlie N. Holmberg
Published by 47North on January 21 2020
Genres: Young adult, Fantasy
Pages: 268
Format: ARC
Source: Publisher
Buy on Amazon
Goodreads
four-stars

The nitty-gritty: A dark and dangerous tale filled with monsters, magic and hard choices.

A mystium is a crossbreed between a mysting and a mortal. Incredibly rare, as most mystings and mortals are not a reproductive match. One can only assume violence to be involved in their creation.

The Will and the Wilds is a unique, lushly written fairy tale with a dash of romance and plenty of danger, and I really enjoyed it! If you think you’d love a story about a handsome, soul-stealing unicorn-like creature who meets and falls for a young girl with a powerful, magical stone, then you will most likely have fun with this as well.

Enna and her father live at the edge of the wildwoods, a dangerous place where monsters called mystings often appear from another realm, the Deep. Enna has been studying and researching mystings her entire life, after her mother was killed by a pack of grinlers. She grows special herbs that keep mystings away and protect their house, but her main line of defense is a magical gem called a Telling Stone given to her by her father, which grows icy cold whenever a mysting is near.

One evening, Enna’s Telling Stone alerts her that a mysting is nearby, but she doesn’t expect two goblers to attack her in her home. Enna’s father kills one of the goblers, but the other gets away. Enna suspects that they may have been after her Telling Stone, which came from the mysting realm. Enna knows the gobler will be back, so her only choice is to find it and kill it, since she knows it won’t rest until it completes its mission. Enna makes a risky decision to summon another mysting to help her.

Maekallus is a narval, a monster who steals human souls. When he finds himself summoned by a beautiful human, he makes a bargain: he’ll help Enna with her gobler problem, but in return, she must give him a kiss. But Enna knows all about narvals and what their kisses can really do. With no other choice, Enna agrees to the bargain, only to regret it when things go very wrong.

I loved Holmberg’s world of the mystings. It’s sort of like a fae world, where the creatures who live there are able to go back and forth through a type of portal. There are also strict rules that govern the world. When mystings come over to the human realm, they can only stay for a short time before they start disintegrating. Most mystings are dangerous to humans, although many humans can’t even see them. Enna is an exception because of her Telling Stone. There’s also a nice backstory about how Enna’s father snuck into the Deep and stole the Telling Stone for his daughter to protect her, which also explains why he’s slightly addled in the head these days. 

I really liked the two main characters, Enna and Maekallus. Enna is fascinated with learning as much as possible about mystings and their hidden realm. She keeps an old journal of her grandmother’s and is constantly scribbling new facts about mystings in the margins. The author includes snippets of these journal entries at the beginning of every chapter, which I thought was a nice touch. And Maekallus is such an interesting character! He has some pretty cool abilities as a narval. He has a sharp horn jutting out of the middle of his forehead that can be removed and used as a spear (!!), a tail with a blade on the end of it, and hooves. He’s also very scary (although in a devastatingly handsome way, lol) and his main gig is stealing human souls with a kiss. I won’t tell you what happens between him and Enna, but let’s just say there is some soul stealing involved (wink wink). We also meet a boy named Tennith who is a potential love interest for Enna—that is until Maekallus comes along. There’s a very funny scene with the three of them, except Tennith can’t see or hear Maekallus, who is making comments about him to Enna. Well, you have to read it for yourself, but I thought it was so well done!

As far as negatives, I did have a couple of issues with the story. First, the pacing lags a little in the middle. At one point in the story, Maekallus is captured and bound by a gobler, which means he’s basically trapped in one place and unable to move very far. This goes on for quite a while, as Enna continually tries to free him, to no avail. It felt as if the characters were going around in circles, both literally and figuratively.

I also found myself wanting to know more about certain world building elements. I felt as if the author whetted our appetites by dropping hints about—for example—Maekallus’s secret origins, and then only offered up cryptic explanations at the end. This is one of those rare examples where the story could have easily been another fifty pages if the author had developed some of her wonderful ideas even further. I was also confused by the ending—which of course I can’t reveal in this review. Some critical events are resolved at the end, but it was rather rushed, and again, I wouldn’t have minded more page time to fully understand what was happening. 

I really haven’t told you much about the plot, since I don’t want to spoil things, but a lot goes on in this story, and Holmberg touches on some interesting themes about being human and just what that means. As far as I know, this is a standalone story, but I wouldn’t mind revisiting this fascinating world.

Big thanks to Wunderkind PR and the publisher for supplying a review copy.

Posted January 25, 2020 by Tammy in 4 stars, Reviews / 34 Comments

Divider

34 responses to “THE WILL AND THE WILDS by Charlie N. Holmberg – Review

  1. Hmm, I am highly intrigued by this! I do love the ‘reluctant allies’ trope where there’s some delicious tension between the two characters who don’t trust each other but need to work together! scary & handsome really works for me too, haha. the issue with the pacing sound a bit annoying, but nothing I can’t deal with, so I think I defs need to get hold of this 😀

  2. Lovely review! Maekallus’ was definitely a big selling point for me, because how freaking cool is that? I want one. xD I definitely agreed about the world-building. That was my one big disappointment, because I loved this world so much that I felt like it should have been expanded. I really want there to be a next one and maybe expand on all the things this one glazed over, because it felt like there was a really thrilling, harrowing, and obviously dangerous storyline just under the surface, and it was so frustrating to not get to see it!
    Sammie @ The Writerly Way recently posted…Diamond City by Francesca Flores || Heist Trope, But With AssassinsMy Profile

    • Tammy

      Maybe once she hears comments about how we need more information, she’ll decide to write a sequel. Fingers crossed!

    • Tammy

      I actually love stories that take place near a wooded area, because there is always something dangerous in the woods:-)

  3. I feel like Holmberg does have some difficulty with pacing in her other novels too but I know this and have been able to accept it and simply overlook it a bit in her books now 😛 Her ideas and concepts are always so out of this world and crazy but I am always impressed with how she manages to make them work?! I am excited to read this one ^.^
    Olivia Roach recently posted…4 Mini Reviews: Shakespeare Edition [Part 2]My Profile

  4. You have absolutely sold me on this story. Your enthusiasm about the creativity and fun is infections, so I’ll be adding this book to my reading soon. Question, though: is there a lot of the, what is now common, YA romance stuff that feels so….COMMON? I don’t typically read YA because I feel like I’m getting the same exact story over and over and over.

    • Tammy

      I thought the romance was very subtle. You might be talking about some tropes like love triangles, which isn’t in this book. But romance definitely isn’t the focus!

  5. Oooh, i like Charlie N. Holmberg! I rarely read fantasy but her stuff is the sort of fantasy i actually quite enjoy. The paper magician series was really cool and i loved the story about the village with dolls.
    This is going on the list 😀

  6. Sarah

    I’m torn- on the one hand, the world building does sound like a lot of fun, the story sounds fairy tale-ish and unique.

    On the other hand- the characters running around in circles and lack of details about some parts sounds like something that would frustrate me pretty heavily. Either way- excellent review as always!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.