THE DEAD HUSBAND COOKBOOK by Danielle Valentine – Review

I received this book for free from the Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

The Dead Husband Cookbook by Danielle Valentine
Published by Sourcebooks Landmark on August 5 2025
Genres: Adult, Mystery, Thriller
Pages: 352
Format: Finished hardcover
Source: Publisher
Buy on Amazon
Goodreads

The nitty-gritty: Family secrets, unreliable narrators and a tell-all memoir make up the bones of this twisty, deliciously entertaining tale.

I’m happy to say that The Dead Husband Cookbook hit many of the same highs for me as Danielle Valentine’s Delicate Condition, a book I absolutely loved. In her latest, the author has taken two seemingly unrelated elements—cooking and publishing—and turned them into a surprisingly effective thriller. She also utilizes the epistolary format, which I loved. If you’re a fan of Rachel Hawkins’ The Heiress, I think you’ll love this book as well. The stories are completely different, but there are similarities in the way the authors tell their tales. This was a blast from start to finish, with only one small side plot near the end that didn’t work for me, hence my half star deduction.

Thea Woods is an editor at Hanes House Press, but her career is on the rocks after a scandalous blowout involving the author of the last book she worked on. With her future teetering on the brink, she’s called into a meeting with her boss Cassandra Hanes, thinking she’s going to be fired.

Instead, Cassandra tells Thea that Hanes House has just acquired the memoir of the infamous food guru/chef Maria Capello, a woman known primarily for the mysterious disappearance of her husband Damien thirty years earlier. This could be the book of the year, since Maria’s fan base is vast, and the rumors surrounding Damien’s disappearance range from suicide to the most outlandish one of all—that Maria killed Damien and made meatballs out of him! But Maria will only work with Hanes House on one condition—she insists that Thea edit the book. To say that Thea is shocked is an understatement. She practically grew up watching Maria on TV.  But she also knows this could be her redemption, provided she can get Maria to give her the real story of what happened to Damien.

But Maria has a few other rules. She insists that Thea edit the book at the Farm, Maria’s vast property in Woodstock, NY and the filming location of her popular TV show, Dinner at the Farm. When she arrives, Maria takes Thea’s cell phone away, claiming she doesn’t want to risk details of her book getting out before publication. Other odd things put Thea on alert: the Wi-Fi at the Farm is spotty at best, and without it, Thea won’t be able to report back to Cassandra. Instead of giving her the complete manuscript, Maria only gives Thea one chapter at a time to edit. With Maria holding back the important details of Damien’s story, Thea begins to get restless and decides to investigate on her own. All is not as it seems at the Farm, and and it’s up to Thea to root out the truth.

The Dead Husband Cookbook is a complex, layered story with a huge cast of unreliable characters, told in two different timelines. Valentine masterfully wrangles her many story elements into a thrilling, fast-paced story where many of the characters are connected in shocking ways. Most of the chapters are from Thea’s point of view and follow her experiences at the Farm, while alternate chapters are excerpts from Maria’s book, The Secret Ingredient. I loved this formatting, especially the flashbacks into Maria’s past, as she tells her story about meeting and falling in love with Damien Capello, how they started an Italian restaurant together, and their eventual falling out when Maria catches Damien cheating early in their marriage. There’s quite a detailed backstory about the couple’s Italian heritage and their love of food and cooking, and I loved that at the end of each book excerpt is one of Maria’s famous recipes (complete with evocative names like “Tell Your Cheating Husband You’re Pregnant Veal”).

Maria herself is something of an enigma. On the outside, she comes across as a sweet, grandmotherly type, but inside she’s as hard as steel. After Damien disappeared, she built herself an empire and became famous for her TV show (think Martha Stewart-type fame). Her narrative paints a picture of an unappreciated wife and mother who struggles in the background while her husband gets all the accolades and attention. Damien is a talented chef, but it’s Maria—at least according to her—who’s created all the recipes and keeps the restaurant running. But is Maria telling the truth? Or is she lying? That’s the big question, and Valentine uses it to her advantage by keeping the reader guessing for most of the story.

I love stories revolving around publishing, and while those details aren’t the main focus of the story, the author includes just enough information about the ins and outs of getting a book to market to make things interesting. Not only is Thea on a deadline to get a first draft manuscript of The Secret Ingredient to Cassandra, but she finds herself caught up in a decades-old mystery surrounding the Capello family. Simply put, she’s pretty stressed out!

A bunch of side characters round out the cast, including Maria’s grown children Enzo and Issie, her granddaughter Ava, Maria’s butcher friend Hank, Enzo’s scheming girlfriend Amy, and of course, the specter of Damien himself, who looms large over the story. Rounding out the cast is Thea’s family, as well as an emotionally charged backstory involving her deadbeat father. As you can see—and I’ve barely scratched the surface—there is a lot going on, but Valentine does a great job of keeping all her ducks in a row.

As for the thriller/horror aspects of the story, the Farm itself feels menacing from the moment Thea arrives. And here’s where I need to add a trigger warning for sensitive animal lovers, because a big part of the story involves meat and where it comes from. Damien Capello insisted on a “farm to table” lifestyle, meaning he built a slaughterhouse on the property. The author includes graphic descriptions of the process, which I’ll admit upset me, but she also uses slaughterhouse props to great effect, like bloody cleavers, blood-stained aprons, and racks of meat hanging in the walk-in freezer. All these visuals went a long way in giving the story a creepy vibe, but do be aware if this subject matter bothers you.

One big twist near the end completely upended my theories of what really happened to Damien, and I loved the ending, which ties everything up, but not in the way I was expecting. The title of Maria’s memoir hides a hint about the truth, and I thought it was brilliantly done. The book itself is a cleverly designed package (including those recipes I mentioned earlier), and even the section titles (“Antipasto,” “Meat,” and “Just Desserts”) tie in with the themes. Overall, I highly recommend The Dead Husband Cookbook for readers who enjoy twisty, multilayered stories.

Big thanks to the publisher for providing a review copy.